Which Is For You? Diaper Genie Complete Vs Elite (Pros & Cons Comparison)

  • We’ve compared the Diaper Genie Complete versus the Elite model 
  • Learn if the Complete model is a good substitute for the Elite 
  • Find out what we liked (and what we didn’t!) for each model 
  • Bonus video: Playtex Diaper Genie Complete - How To

Do you need a new diaper pail for your nursery?

Are you looking for a product that can hold up to a lot of use?

Do you want to check out the Diaper Genie line?

Below, we’ll compare the Diaper Genie Elite, which went off the market a few years ago, and the newer Diaper Genie Complete. This comparison should help you determine whether or not the Complete is really a reasonable alternative to its predecessor or not.

Read on to compare the Diaper Genie Elite vs Complete models more in-depth.

1. Diaper Genie Complete

Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail with Odor Lock Technology, White

The Diaper Genie Complete is a sturdy diaper pail that’s sure to work great in any nursery. This durable product is made out of easy-to-clean plastic and designed to hold in odors without making it too complicated for you to throw away your dirty diapers, either. And since it comes from the well-known Diaper Genie brand, you know you’re getting a product that is sure to last a long time and remain an important part of your child’s nursery setup for as long as you need it—and maybe for your next little one, too!


  • This product features an upgraded and more modern design that looks sleek and sophisticated and is sure to fit into just about any nursery setup with no trouble.
  • This diaper pail features a built-in carbon filter that helps reduce both smells and bacteria and is activated naturally without the need for complicated equipment.
  • This Diaper Genie model has a revamped clamping lid that is air-tight and keeps smells locked in even better than ever before.
  • Just like previous models, this product is designed to be ergonomic and make it easier to reach when you throw out dirty diapers.

What We Liked

  • We like how lightweight this product is. It’s very easy to pick up this diaper pail and move it around as needed, and this also makes it much easier to empty it and clean it out when it’s time to take care of its upkeep, too. This is a very user-friendly product that isn’t too complicated to work with when you need to change the filters or refills, and overall, we think its ease of use and lighter weight are great selling points.

What Could Be Improved

  • The biggest downside of this product is that it simply isn’t as large as the previous Diaper Genie models were. Where older models could hold over 30 dirty diapers at once, this version holds less than half that, making it simply not as powerful of a product overall.


  • This Diaper Genie model is very easy to keep clean.
  • This product comes in five different cute colors to match any nursery.
  • This diaper pail is ready to go out of the box and comes with everything you need to get started.


  • It can be very difficult to remove the dirty bags from this product and replace them with new ones.
  • Some customers have had issues with this product not opening or closing all the way, which contributes to a smell issue.
  • Many customers report the hinges breaking easily on this product.

2. Diaper Genie Elite

One of the best-selling diaper pails on the market in the past, the Diaper Genie Elite is a very easy-to-use and long-lasting product that may customers have loved over the years. This product provides hands-free diaper disposal and is designed to lock in odor so that your nursery, bathroom, or any other room of your home doesn’t have to suffer from the smell of dirty diapers. With this customer favorite, you’ll never again have to worry about bacteria or bad smells plaguing the spaces where your baby spends his or her time.


  • This pail is tall enough that you don’t have to bend over to access it, making it an ideal choice for anyone who is dealing with back pain or who just wants a more ergonomically-friendly diaper pail.
  • This pail features a foot pedal to help open it so you don’t have to get your hands dirty or near any bacteria when you throw away dirty diapers.
  • This product contains built-in antimicrobial features that keep smells from escaping, even when you open the lid to throw away new garbage.
  • The pail itself is capable of holding up to 38 diapers, and it comes with enough refill bags to hold up to 270 diapers before you’ll need to purchase additional refills.

What We Liked

  • We like how easy it is to operate this product by simply using your foot. We think it’s nice to be able to toss out trash without having to have a free hand to open up the lid to the garbage can, especially when you’re holding a baby or trying to deal with a soiled diaper. There is no more knob-turning required on this model of Diaper Genie, so it’s easier to manage overall than its predecessors were.

What Could Be Improved

  • We feel that the worst element of this product is that there’s no way to push down the dirty diapers to make room for new ones without using your hands to do so. It’s not an ideal situation to stick your hand into a pail of dirty diapers, so we think it would be better if this product was designed with some means of pushing down the old trash.


  • This product is taller than many similar products on the market, so it’s easier to deal with overall and won’t cause pain when bending over to reach it.
  • This product operates quietly, so you don’t have to worry about waking up your baby when throwing out diapers.
  • This product features a carbon filter that helps reduce the presence of bacteria.


  • This product is no longer on the market and is very difficult to find secondhand or in stores that may have had them in stock a little longer than it was available.
  • The refills required for this product are very expensive and can also be difficult to find.
  • It may take some time to change the bags for this product and you will have to deal with the smell of the dirty diapers in the meantime.


Do you feel like you have a better idea of the differences between these two models of diaper pails? As you can see, they aren’t entirely different from each other, but they’re not the same either. Both are good options for your nursery, but it can be tough to make up your mind about which to go for.

So in the Diaper Genie Complete vs Elite competition, which is the real winner? Overall, we feel that the older, off the market Diaper Genie Elite is the better product. It holds more diapers and is just a better and sturdier diaper pail than the newer model. However, it can be very challenging to find it in stock, so you may be better off going with the Complete instead for this reason!



You Might Also Like