5 Best Pacifier For Breastfeeding Newborn Products Online

Are you considering giving your breastfeeding newborn a pacifier?

Are you concerned about any risks you might face from doing this?

Would you like to know the best pacifier to use while breastfeeding your baby?

In this article, you’ll learn everything you need to know about choosing the right pacifier for your newborn little one. You’ll discover reviews for some of the best pacifiers for breastfeeding and you’ll even find out a little extra information to help you decide whether or not this is the right decision for you and your child, too.

If you’ve ever had questions about using a pacifier for your newborn while he or she is breastfeeding, we hope to have an answer! So let’s get started.

Don't have the time to check out the whole list?
Here are our TOP FAVORITE PICKS:

OUR FAVORITE PICK
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Blue, 0-3 Months, 2 Count
Vanilla Scent Soothie Newborn Pacifiers - 2 Pack
Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Everyday Pacifier, 0-6 Months, 2 Count (Colors will vary)
JollyPop 0-3 Months Pacifier Single Pack Vanilla Scented - Teal
NUK Airflow Orthodontic Pacifier with Penguin Design in Boy Colors, 0-6 Months
$3.59
$7.99
$5.99
from $4.65
$5.98
-
3284 Reviews
60 Reviews
63 Reviews
25 Reviews
26 Reviews
OUR FAVORITE PICK
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Blue, 0-3 Months, 2 Count
$3.59
3284 Reviews
Vanilla Scent Soothie Newborn Pacifiers - 2 Pack
$7.99
60 Reviews
Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Everyday Pacifier, 0-6 Months, 2 Count (Colors will vary)
$5.99
63 Reviews
JollyPop 0-3 Months Pacifier Single Pack Vanilla Scented - Teal
from $4.65
-
25 Reviews
NUK Airflow Orthodontic Pacifier with Penguin Design in Boy Colors, 0-6 Months
$5.98
26 Reviews

Last update on 2017-12-11 at 00:58 Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Giving a Newborn a Pacifier

You may have heard rumors or myths that newborn babies should never be given pacifiers—or you might have been repeatedly told that there’s no reason not to give your baby one. When it comes down to it, the right decision for you and your child may not be the same as it is for another family, and that’s okay. What matters is understanding the pros and cons of giving your newborn a pacifier as well as making sure you choose the best pacifier for newborn breastfeeding.

Benefits

  • check

    Some pediatricians believe that individual babies may have a stronger need to suck than others. This largely has to do with comfort, but it also relates to a newborn baby’s instinctive desire to suck. You may have a baby who simply needs this more than another baby might, and if so, that’s okay. If this is the case, you’ll have a much happier baby if you go ahead and let your child use a pacifier.

  • check

    Some studies have shown that using a pacifier decreases the risk of SIDS in younger infants. The American Academy of Pediatrics believes that the use of a pacifier in younger infants can cut back on the risk of SIDS as well. This is largely because SIDS is believed to be related to fear. The use of a pacifier can reduce the feeling of fear in young babies.

  • check

    Pacifier use can help soothe and calm your baby and improve difficult sleep schedules. If you have a fussy baby or a baby who isn’t sleeping well at night, you can offer your child some comfort through the use of a pacifier. Choose the best pacifiers to use while breastfeeding and your baby is sure to sleep more easily and calm down from fussiness more quickly.

Disadvantages

  • Babies who use a pacifier for too long run the risk of increased ear infections, intestinal infections, and yeast infections of the mouth. This generally isn’t a problem if you discontinue the use of the pacifier by the time your baby is 6 months old. However, it can be challenging to break the binky habit as your baby gets older, so many children continue to use theirs much longer than this. Be sure to check in frequently with your child’s pediatrician if this is a concern for you.

  • Babies who have a cold will have a tougher time breathing well if they’re also trying to suck on a pacifier. Your baby will likely want to self-soothe using a pacifier if he or she is sick, but this may make breathing more challenging and uncomfortable. If you use the pacifier according to its safety directions, this shouldn’t be a health risk, but it may make your baby fussier while he or she is sick.

  • Your newborn probably won’t be able to hold a pacifier in his or her mouth during the night and may wake up crying for it frequently if it falls out. Even the best pacifiers for breastfeeding babies can easily fall out of a young baby’s mouth throughout the night. This will mean you’ll have to be up often to put the pacifier back in your child’s mouth when this happens, and it may mean a less restful night for you.

1. Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Blue, 0-3 Months, 2 Count

Choose the Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier when you want the best pacifier for breastfeeding newborn babies in hospitals around the country. This is a pediatrician and a doctor-recommended pacifier that is designed with your baby’s orthodontics in mind. It’s BPA-free, easy to clean and even easier to sterilize, too. With this two-pack, your newborn will be set for a while with a colorful and cute pacifier that is specifically intended for use by younger infants.

Pros

Cons

  • This is the most affordable set of pacifiers on our list and is one of the best-selling and most highly recommended options available as well.

  • The softer pacifiers for younger babies are also very safe for use while your child is teething and will be chewing on everything.

  • These pacifiers may fall out of babies’ mouths very easily, especially when they are still young and unable to hold their mouths closed throughout the night.

  • Some customers have reported receiving pacifiers with a hole in the nipple tip, resulting in too much airflow into the baby’s mouth.

2. JollyPop 0-3 Months Pacifier

JollyPop 0-3 Months Pacifier Single Pack Vanilla Scented - Teal

If you’re looking for the best pacifier for breastfeeding newborns and you want something that’s a little extra cute, too, check out the JollyPop 0-3 Months Pacifier. This 100% silicone pacifier is soft and flexible, making it perfect for little mouths that haven’t developed any teeth yet. It’s vanilla scented to make it a little more enticing to your little one, and it comes in four different bright and cheerful colors so you can stock up on all of your baby’s favorites.

Pros

Cons

  • This pacifier is available in a preemie size, unlike many of the others available.

  • This is a very flexible and soft pacifier that’s good for babies who don’t have any teeth yet.

  • There is a chance that the vanilla scent in these pacifiers may be irritating to your baby’s skin or may cause headaches in any parents or caregivers who are very sensitive to smells.

  • Some babies are not able to keep this pacifier in their mouths because of its shape.

Check it out on Amazon

3. NUK Airflow Orthodontic Pacifier

NUK Airflow Orthodontic Pacifier with Penguin Design in Boy Colors, 0-6 Months

Are you looking for a pacifier that’s a little more stylish than some of the other plain colors listed here? With the NUK Airflow Orthodontic Pacifier, your baby can enjoy a two-pack of binkies that include a penguin print and a multi-colored star print. These pacifiers are specifically designed to fit snugly under your baby’s nose, and they feature extra holes for maximum airflow and a reduced risk of skin irritation, too.

Pros

Cons

  • These pacifiers are designed for babies who are uninterested in more traditional shapes and nipple styles, and they tend to be well accepted by newborns.

  • The handle on the outside of these pacifiers is not easy for young babies to reach and pull out on their own.

  • These are heavier pacifiers than some of the others listed here and may fall out of younger babies’ mouths more easily because of this.

  • When cleaning, water can get trapped on the inside of these pacifiers and be difficult to get out.

4. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Everyday Pacifier

Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Everyday Pacifier, 0-6 Months, 2 Count (Colors will vary)

For the best pacifier for breastfeeding babies that features a cute design, check out the Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Everyday Pacifier. This pacifier can be purchased in a 0 to 6-month option or one for older children, but if you go with the 0-6 choice, you’ll be bringing home a well-designed and perfectly orthodontic binky that your little one will love. It’s safe for use by even the youngest of babies and features a textured bottle-style nipple design that makes it easier to encourage your child to try it out for the first time.

Pros

Cons

  • These pacifiers are designed to prevent younger babies from getting their lips around the edges, meaning they can’t be dropped out of the mouth as easily.

  • These pacifiers arrive in safe and sterile packaging that’s easy to open and ensures the binkies will be ready for use right away.

  • Because of their design, these pacifiers may be a little more difficult to keep clean than many of the others listed here.

  • Many customers have had trouble receiving the color or pattern they have requested with this set of pacifiers.

5. Vanilla Scent Soothie Newborn Pacifiers

Vanilla Scent Soothie Newborn Pacifiers - 2 Pack

With these Vanilla Scent Soothie Newborn Pacifiers, your baby will be safely and securely enjoying all the comfort that comes from a pacifier in no time. These latex-free pacifiers are as stylish as they are durable and safe. They’re highly recommended by medical professionals and are made from easy-to-clean silicone with no BPA. Available in a pack of two, these are very high-quality pacifiers that are sure to please your newborn and help transition your child smoothly and gently into pacifier use.

Pros

Cons

  • The vanilla scent is enticing to babies and is sure to keep your little one sucking on this pacifier for hours without any fussiness.

  • This is a pacifier that is highly recommended by hospitals and pediatricians, and it may even be the same pacifier your child might have used in the hospital after birth.

  • These pacifiers are a little bit more expensive than most of the others on our list, although they still are very affordable.

  • Some babies who have very sensitive skin may develop an allergic reaction from these pacifiers.

Conclusion

So what is the best pacifier for a breastfeeding baby? When it comes down to it, the final decision is entirely up to you. You may want to pick up a few different options from our list and try them out for yourself, or you might find that your baby loves the very first one you choose.

Although all of these are excellent items that are sure to do the trick, we recommend the JollyPop 0-3 Months Pacifier as our number one choice. This is a great pacifier that is easy to keep clean, easy to use, and even comes with a pleasing vanilla scent that makes it nicer for babies and for you as well.

This pacifier is available in many different colors and looks cute while your baby is using it, too. Although it may fall out of your baby’s mouth while he or she is still very young, the pros of this pacifier outweigh the cons. And best of all, it’s one of the more affordable options on our list, too.

This is our number one pick, but no matter which pacifier you go with—even if you shop around outside of our list—we have a few suggestions to keep in mind when you’re looking for the right option for your child. These aren’t the only qualities to look for in a pacifier for your little one, but they can help you get started.

can you get a tattoo when your breastfeeding
  • plus

    Choose a pacifier with a good airflow. Babies may be less likely to want to use their pacifiers if they have a difficult time breathing while sucking on them. This is especially true when babies get a stuffy nose or a head cold. Be sure to choose one that doesn’t offer too much airflow either, however.

  • plus

    Pick a pacifier that’s designed to fit your baby’s face. Some pacifiers are not sculpted to the shape of your baby’s face, and these are more likely to fall out of your child’s mouth easily. This isn’t to say that these aren’t good choices, but they may be more difficult to use.

  • plus

    Go with a pacifier that’s easy to keep clean. You should pick one that’s made of baby-safe materials and can be run through the dishwasher or boiled for sterilization as needed. Take care if you’re buying a hard plastic pacifier that may hold water in nooks and crannies after cleaning.

Keep these tips in mind and you’ll be well on your way to finding the perfect newborn-safe pacifier that’s sure to keep your breastfeeding baby happy and satisfied for a long time to come.

Bonus Video